Fansubbing: Myths and FAQ
By DarkMirage - 11/12/2004
Recently, Media Factory Inc.
issued a legal statement to
AnimeSuki,
requesting the removal of the site's BitTorrent listings for MFI intellectual
properties. This turn of events took the fansubbing community by surprise as it
was not an American company, but a Japanese one that made the request. The
responses were loud and violent, as teenagers with questionable language
abilities flocked to forums and chatrooms, each and every one of them eager to
express his/her discontents through deep and profound posts that often consisted
of words not exceeding four-characters long. The opinions expressed can
generally be summarized as "confused" and "misguided", with some even nearing the
realm of "retardation". This has significantly lowered my
hopes for the future of humanity and so I have decide to create this semi-FAQ to
facilitate my crusade against idiocy and ignorance. Don't get me wrong, I have nothing against
fansubs. I am part of a fansubbing group and I find fansubbers in general
to be fine folks. I just hate those morons going on in forums about their
constitutional rights to download and watch fansubs.
Pardon my poor English, for, unlike many of those forum-goers, it is not my
mother-tongue.
- Fansubs are legal.
The unauthorized reproduction and distribution of copyrighted material is far from
legal. See: Copyright.
- Fansubs are legal as long as the series in question is not licensed
for distribution in the region where the fansubs are being distributed in.
Completely false. Fansubs are illegal whether the series is licensed
for distribution or
not. This is because the copyright (which is completely unrelated to the
right of distribution) applies even in countries where the
series is not distributed in. See:
the Berne Convention, specifically the parts about
nationality of author,
rights of
translation and
rights of
reproduction. Here's a
full list of signatories
to the Convention. It is interesting to note
that the mere act of making an unauthorized translation available for public
usage is already illegal, much less the actual copyrighted footage.
- Fansubs are legal because they are not being done for commercial purposes.
False. Fansubs are illegal whether they are being exchanged for
objects of monetary worth. Just like copies of pirated software are illegal
whether they are being offered for download or sold at roadside stalls. See:
Statutory Damages. As
for the so-called "educational" purposes claimed by some
fansubbing zealots, please
refer to the question below.
- Fansubs are legal in America and some other countries under the Fair Use
/ Fair Dealing clause.
No. No they are not. The unauthorized
reproduction, translation and subsequent distribution of the entire length
of a copyrighted animation is not protected by Fair Use in anyway
whatsoever. The only protections Fair Use might give would be, for example, if you were to
make a self-subtitled copy of a work you own legally and view it in your own
privacy. This can include close friends and family, but whether all two
hundred of your fellow anime club members count for close friends will be
decided by the jury and not you. Using parts of a copyrighted work for the purpose of parodies, reviews,
news report, teaching material etc. is
also covered under Fair Use as long as they do not constitute a huge portion of the work in question.
This means that fansubs do not qualify. For a more detailed explanation of
Fair Use, see here.
- Fansubs are legal... somehow.
No. They are not. Just give up already.
- My friend/brother/uncle/cousin-twice-removed/random guy on
IRC/etcetera told me that fansubbing is legal because of [insert reason here].
He/she/it lies.
- If unlicensed fansubs are illegal, why were they tolerated? And why
the sudden change?
To put it simply: fansubs helped to promote anime back when the word
"anime" was not part of English and most animations on TV were Hana-Barbara,
Disney and whatever else you Americans had. They were tolerated by Japanese
companies for this purpose. Most studios also felt that it was not worth the
effort to sue North American fansubbers, as they had, at that time, no assets in North
America to protect. Suing could also potentially isolate their new fans and
close up a potential market.
Today however, you ("you" being North
Americans) can watch anime on cable TV, buy anime DVDs from any DVD stores,
join an anime club in school and read about all the latest anime news on the
internet. Fansubs today no longer play that single vital role in promoting a
new series to foreign audiences. Yet because of their mass-availability through the internet,
they are now hurting the sales of legitimate DVDs in North America, Asia and
other regions. For this reason, Japanese companies have slowly started to
take actions against fansubbers
instead of waiting for a foreign distributor to do the job.
- Japanese companies cannot sue American fansubbers and need to do it through American distributors.
False. Japanese companies have always been able to take legal actions against North American fansubbers. They just chose not to because they decided that committing the resources to do so was
not worth the effort. Contracting an American law firm to represent you in
US court is not exactly cheap and certainly time-consuming. It was, and
still is, simpler to let an American distributor do the job. However, more
Japanese companies are now willing to take actions directly to protect their
interests due to developments in recent years such as the high broadband internet penetration and the exponential growth of anime subculture in North America.
- I am poor! I can't afford legitimate DVDs! Those evil money-hungry companies have no right to make me pay so much for my anime!!!
The companies made those DVDs and the contents within. They, as the copyright holders, have complete control over what they want to do with their intellectual properties. No one is "making" you buy anime DVDs. You have logical thinking skills and free-will (or so I'd like to believe); if a product is overpriced, then don't buy it! As for companies being money-hungry, please see: Capitalism.
- I don't live in North America or any place where legitimate anime can be
purchased!
Tough luck. Entertainment isn't a basic human right. The companies have no obligations to make
sure that their products are made available to everyone. It's not oxygen for
god's sake.
If you find any factual errors in this FAQ, please feel free to
e-mail me in a
non-threatening manner. I will correct any mistakes ASAP.
You may use the contents of this page in anyway you deem necessary to raise copyright awareness in the fansubbing community.
©2004 DarkMirage